At first glance, Iceland appears to be a near-utopia — a country where the buses run on time, healthcare works, the elderly are cared for, children are respected, and even young couples can afford to start a family. In this land of geothermal energy and breathtaking landscapes, door locks are almost ornamental. But beneath the snow, the moss, and the glowing lava lies a darker, more complex Iceland — one that Ragnar Jónasson and Katrín Jakobsdóttir capture masterfully in their novel ‘Reykjavík a crime story‘. The pairing of Jónasson and Jakobsdóttir may seem improbable at first. He is a celebrated crime novelist and law professor, co-founder of the Iceland Noir festival and the man who brought Agatha Christie to Icelandic readers. She is none other than Iceland’s former Prime Minister (2017–2024), a scholar of Icelandic literature whose university thesis focused on detective fiction. Yet, both share a lifelong fascination with crime stories and with the moral ambiguities that hide behind serene façades. Their collaboration began in early 2020, in the middle of the pandemic that Jakobsdóttir herself was leading the nation through. Together, they conceived a story rooted in Iceland’s past — a cold case that begins in 1956 and finds its chilling resolution twenty years later, during Reykjavík’s bicentennial celebrations of 1986. Both authors, then children, still remember that historical year. At the heart of ‘Reykjavík a crime story’ lies the mysterious disappearance of Lára, an innocent young woman spending her summer working for a wealthy, respectable family on the small island of Viðey — a real islet just off Reykjavík, known for its solitude, seabirds, and the whispers of the wind. When Lára vanishes without a trace, her employers claim she simply quit and left. Yet she never returns home. The only people on the island were the couple, the ferryman, and the birds — so what really happened to her? A young policeman investigates, but his efforts are thwarted by institutional indifference and subtle pressure from above. The trail goes cold, and Lára is lost to the sea of unsolved mysteries. Two decades later, a journalist reopens the case, shaking the pillars of Icelandic respectability and provoking a scandal that coincides with the historic Reagan–Gorbachev summit. Suddenly, the eyes of the nation — and of Lára herself, in a metaphorical sense — turn back upon Iceland’s collective conscience.
This book is not just a crime novel; it is a mirror held up to a society that prides itself on purity, equality, and integrity, yet harbours shadows like any other. Jónasson and Jakobsdóttir’s Iceland is a place of contrasts — pristine yet corrupted, luminous yet opaque. Their writing peels back the myth of the flawless Nordic paradise and replaces it with something far more human: a small, isolated nation where secrets can last as long as the winter night. This elegant, finely constructed thriller blends atmospheric tension with psychological depth. It shows that even in the most transparent societies, darkness endures — sometimes not in the landscape, but in the heart.
Buy ‘Reykjavík a crime story‘ by Ragnar Jónasson and Katrín Jakobsdóttir on Bookshop.org
The books suggested in this article are linked to Bookshop.org, an online bookstore whose mission is to financially support local, independent bookstores in the US and UK: we at ATN believe that indie bookstores are essential to a healthy culture. When you buy through these links, a small percentage of the (unchanged) price helps us keeping All Things Nordic free for all users
